| Champion | Won Title | Location | Lost Title |
| Roddy Piper | 03/08/1998 {1} | Vineland, NJ | 04/16/1998 |
| Dory Funk Jr. | 04/16/1998 | Seattle, WA | 09/13/1998 |
| Slim Dragger | 09/13/1998 | New York, NY | 11/02/1998 |
| Nightmare | 11/02/1998 | North Richland Hills, TX | 11/06/1998 {2} |
| Adam Fierce | 09/24/1999 {3} | Orlando, FL | 10/21/1999 |
| Robert Stevens | 10/21/1999 | Detroit, MI | 11/26/99 |
| Kid Capricorn | 11/26/99 | Lakeland, FL | 1/22/00 |
| Agent Mandell | 1/22/00 | Calgary, Alberta | 5/15/00 |
| Aaron C. Spiering | 5/15/00 | Rimousky, Quebec | 6/19/00 |
| Michael Lennox | 6/19/00 | Brisbane, Australia | 8/6/00 |
| CJ Rowell | 8/6/00 | Twin Falls, ID | 9/16/00 |
| Kai A. Lewis | 9/16/00 | Baltimore, MD | 9/26/00 |
| Eric Dane | 9/26/00 | Orlando, FL | 11/26/00 |
| Dan Dixon | 11/26/00 | Macon, GA | 01/28/01 |
| Lance Panzer | 01/28/01 | Calgary, Alberta, Canada | 05/19/01 |
| Ryan Matthews | 05/19/01 | Japan | 05/27/01 |
| Jake Rockwell | 05/27/01 {4} | Los Angeles, CA | 06/23/01 |
| Diablo | 06/23/01 | Boston, Mass | 09/29/01|
| Tyler Cross | 09/29/01 | Seward, Alaska | 12/23/01 |
| Vic Vary | 12/23/01 | England | |
| Ken Jansen | Minnesota | 03/31/02 | |
| Vic Vary [2] | 03/31/02 {5} | Lafayette, LA |
| {1} | tournament final over Slim Dragger to become the first board recognized champion. |
| {2} | title retired in favor of NeWA International Heavyweight title |
| {3} | Fierce, the reigning Canadian Heavyweight Champion defeated Nightmare, the reigning U.S. Heavyweight champion to unify both titles. |
| {4} | Pinned Lance Panzer in a triple threat match. |
| {5} | Pinned Mike Sloan in a four-way match |