| Champion | Won Title | Location | Lost Title |
| Brad Armstrong | 04/01/1998 {1} | Garfield, NJ | 05/06/1998 |
| Reckless Youth | 05/06/1998 | East Rutherford, NJ | 06/05/1998 |
| Sheik Christopher | 06/05/1998 | Uniondale, NY | 07/15/1998 |
| Juventud Guerrera | 07/15/1998 | Atlanta, GA | 12/1998 {2} |
| {1} | tournament final over Brian Christopher. |
| {2} | title vacated by Guerrera; retired on 01/23/1999. |