| Champion | Won Title | Location | Lost Title |
| Hyuk Suh Kim | 01/23/1999 | Honolulu, HI {1} | 05/02/1999 {2} |
| Dark Man X | 05/09/1999 {3} | Tokyo, Japan | 05/28/1999 |
| Orange Hatter | 05/28/1999 | Des Moines, IA | 05/28/1999 |
| Jim Dalton | 05/28/1999 | Des Moines, IA | 09/10/99 |
| Todd Knight | 09/10/99 | Minneapolis, MN | 10/31/1999 |
| Angel of Death | 10/31/1999 | Detroit, MI | 11/11/1999 |
| Silverstrike | 11/11/1999 | Vancouver, WA | 11/20/99 |
| Bryan Sensation | 11/20/99 | Anchorage, AK | 11/26/99 |
| Darnell Jenkins | 11/26/99 | Lakeland, FL | 12/11/99 |
| Richie Clement | 12/11/99 | Juneau, AK | 12/30/99 |
| Drew Jacobs | 12/30/99 | Portland, OR | 2/12/00 |
| El Scorcho | 2/12/00 | Amsterdam, Holland | 2/20/00 {4} |
| Ray Masters | 2/27/00 {5} | Seattle, WA | 4/18/00 |
| Brian Hale | 4/18/00 | Fairbanks, AK | 4/30/00 |
| Richie Clement [2] | 4/30/00 | Kodiak, AK | 5/21/00 |
| Kestrel Falcos | 5/21/00 | Athens, OH | 7/23/00 |
| Jim Dalton [2] | 7/23/00 | Philadelphia, PA | 8/30/00 |
| Sandy Sandoval | 8/30/00 | Cleveland, OH | 9/26/00 |
| Namada Kamakazi | 9/26/00 | Orlando, FL | 10/08/00 |
| Kestrel Falcos [2] | 10/08/00 | Cleveland, OH | 11/16/00 |
| Dark Tara | 11/16/00 | New York, NY | 02/19/01 |
| Treize Zero | 02/19/01 | Atlanta, GA | 03/03/01 |
| Kid Thunder | 03/03/01 | Anchorage, Alaska | 04/01/01 |
| Kestrel Falcos [3] | 04/01/01 | Ohio State University, Ohio | 05/01/01 |
| Benoit Dreygon | 05/01/01 | Cardiff, Wales | 06/03/01 |
| Ozmodious | 06/03/01 | Fall River, Mass. | 09/24/01 |
| Blade | 09/24/01 | Boston, Mass. | 12/17/01 |
| "The Tiger" Adam Burke | 12/17/01 | Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada | 02/11/02 |
| The Jayster | 02/11/02 | Columbus, Ohio | 03/31/02 |
| "The Tiger" Adam Burke [2] | 03/31/02 | Lafayette, LA | Retired |
| Misty | 02/29/12 | London, England | 06/29/12 |
| Zak Phenom | 06/29/12 | Albuquerque, NM | Current |
| {1} | tournament final over Juventud Guerrera to become first champion |
| {2} | Title vacated due to Kim winning the International title on 04/26/1999 |
| {3} | pins Jim Dalton in an eight man match to win vacant title. |
| {4} | El Scorcho vacated the title and retired from active competition. |
| {5} | defeated King Neptune for the vacant title. |